2009 All-Northern Athletics Conference Women's Soccer Awards
| Defensive Player of the Year: | Cait Hartman, Aurora |
| Offensive Player of the Year: | Haley Pschirrer, Aurora |
| Freshman of the Year: | Britney Schenck, Aurora |
| Coach of the Year: | Jeff Halsema, Dominican |
| First Team All-Northern Athletics Conference | ||||
| Ilana Bar-Av | Edgewood | GK | Sr. | Madison, Wis. (Memorial) |
| Jacqui Lani | Dominican | GK | Sr. | Green Bay, Wis. (Preble) |
| Emily Daniels | Edgewood | D | Jr. | Slinger, Wis. |
| Cait Hartman | Aurora | D | Jr. | Parker, Colo. (Ponderosa) |
| Rachel Kleba | Concordia Wisconsin | D | Jr. | Hartland, Wis. (Lake County Lutheran) |
| Liz Phipps | Dominican | D | So. | Bloomington, Ill. (University High) |
| Nikki Counsell | Aurora | M | Sr. | Oconomowoc, Wis. |
| Mindy Donald | MSOE | M | Jr. | Fredonia, Wis. (Ozaukee) |
| Tammi Hagensick | Edgewood | M | Sr. | Madison, Wis. (Memorial) |
| Danielle Grable | Marian | F | Sr. | Neenah, Wis. |
| Ellie LaFond | Alverno | F | Sr. | Waukesha, Wis. (West) |
| Jessica Novickas | Aurora | F | Sr. | Highland Park, Ill. |
| Becky Ott | Concordia Wisconsin | F | Jr. | Menasha, Wis. (St. Mary Central) |
| Haley Pschirrer | Aurora | F | So. |
Peoria, Ill. (Notre Dame) |
| Second Team All-Northern Athletics Conference | ||||
| Mary Ryan | Concordia Wisconsin | GK | Jr. | Iron Mountain, Mich. (Kingsford) |
| Mariel Bartolutti | Marian | D | Jr. | Fond du Lac, Wis. |
| Sara Hoffman | Marian | D | So. | Wisconsin Rapids, Wis. (Lincoln) |
| Britney Schenck | Aurora | D | Fr. | St. Charles, Mo. (Orchard Farm) |
| Karina Weideman | MSOE | D | So. | Waukesha, Wis. (West) |
| Amanda Hertz | Aurora | M | Sr. | Las Vegas, Nev. (Silverado) |
| Jamie Janczak | MSOE | M | So. | Germantown, Wis. |
| Katie Petty | Dominican | M | Jr. | Crystal Lake, Ill. (Marian Central) |
| Lauren Straehler | Concordia Wisconsin | M | Fr. | Pewaukee, Wis. (Kettle Moraine) |
| Kim Kriese | Marian | F | Jr. | Stevens Point, Wis. (SPASH) |
| Abby Moder | Edgewood | F | Fr. | Menasha, Wis. (Neenah) |
| Kelly Petty | Dominican | F | Fr. | Crystal Lake, Ill. (Marian Central) |
| Emily Waldorf | Concordia Wisconsin | F | Jr. | Hartford, Wis. (Kettle Moraine Luth.) |
| Rachel Wilson | Benedictine | F | Fr. | Albuquerque, N.M. (St. Pius X) |
| Honorable Mention | ||||
| Emma Lumpe | MSOE | GK | Fr. | Lawrence, Kan. |
| Lindsay Dyal | Concordia Chicago | D | Fr. | Eagle River, Alaska (Chugiak) |
| Autumn Gaylor | Lakeland | D | So. | Ingleside, Ill. (Grant) |
| Allison Plank | MSOE | D | Jr. | Appleton, Wis. (West) |
| Jessica Thompson | Edgewood | D | Sr. | Waukesha, Wis. (West) |
| Michelle Yeager | Dominican | D | Fr. | Noblesville, Ind. (Cathedral) |
| Kristina Borts | Lakeland | M | So. | Milwaukee, Wis. (Greenfield) |
| Alex Brenner | Alverno | M | Sr. | West Allis, Wis. (Nathan Hale) |
| Kelsey Kochanowski | Alverno | M | Fr. | Oak Creek, Wis. |
| Cathy Palese | Concordia Wisconsin | M | Sr. | Milwaukee, Wis. (Lutheran) |
| Cheyenne Martinez-Trevino | Concordia Chicago | F | Fr. | Santa Maria, Calif. (Righetti) |
| Adrienne Ryba | Dominican | F | Fr. | Roselle, Ill. (Lake Park) |
| Lauren Souza | Concordia Chicago | F | Jr. | Kailua, Hawaii (Kalaheo) |
| All-Freshman
Team |
||||
| Emma Lumpe | MSOE | GK | Fr. | Lawrence, Kan. |
| Liz Wong | Aurora | GK | Fr. | Tucson, Ariz. (Canyon Del Oro) |
| Kelly Bolli | Concordia Wisconsin | D | Fr. | Eagle, Wis. (Palmyra-Eagle) |
| Victoria Falcon | MSOE | D | Fr. | North Bend, Wash. (Mount Si) |
| Britney Schenck | Aurora | D | Fr. | St. Charles, Mo. (Orchard Farm) |
| Michelle Yeager | Dominican | D | Fr. | Noblesville, Ind. (Cathedral) |
| Kelsey Kochanowski | Alverno | M | Fr. | Oak Creek, Wis. |
| Lauren Straehler | Concordia Wisconsin | M | Fr. | Pewaukee, Wis. (Kettle Moraine) |
| Brittany Graham | Marian | F | Fr. | Alvin, Wis. (Phelps) |
| Cheyenne Martinez-Trevino | Concordia Chicago | F | Fr. | Santa Maria, Calif. (Righetti) |
| Abby Moder | Edgewood | F | Fr. | Menasha, Wis. (Neenah) |
| Kelly Petty | Dominican | F | Fr. | Crystal Lake, Ill. (Marian Central) |
| Adrienne Ryba | Dominican | F | Fr. | Roselle, Ill. (Lake Park) |
| Rachel Wilson | Benedictine | F | Fr. | Albuquerque, N.M. (St. Pius X) |
| All-Sportsmanship Team | ||||
| Kelly Sunstrom | Alverno | D | Jr. | Muskego, Wis. (Martin Luther) |
| Molly Thayer | Aurora | M | Fr. | Aurora, Ill. (Waubonsie Valley) |
| Juana Montalvo | Benedictine | M | Sr. | West Chicago, Ill. |
| Kelly Engelking | Concordia Chicago | D | So. | Elgin, Ill. (Burlington Central) |
| Rachel Kleba | Concordia Wisconsin | D | Jr. | Hartland, Wis. (Lake Country Lutheran) |
| Jacqui Lani | Dominican | GK | Sr. | Green Bay, Wis. (Preble) |
| Kelsey Beck | Edgewood | F | Fr. | Oregon, Wis. (McFarland) |
| Jessica Hopfinger | Lakeland | M | Sr. | Hustisford, Wis. |
| Emily Kutz | Maranatha | M | Sr. | Cambridge, Wis. (Utica Christian) |
| Sarah Hoffman | Marian | D | So. | Wisconsin Rapids, Wis. (Lincoln) |
| Heidi Brehmer | MSOE | F | Jr. | Eagle River, Alaska (Chugiak) |
| Kaite Sloan | Wisconsin Lutheran | GK | Jr. | Omaha, Neb. (Nebraska Lutheran) |
