2009 Northern Athletics Conference Football Awards
| Co-Offensive Players of the Year: | Jacob Heinemeyer, Lakeland & Mike Marotta, Concordia Chicago |
| Defensive Player of the Year: | Mike Budzinski, Aurora |
| Co-Freshmen of the Year: | John Alessi, Benedictine & Zach Shaw, Wisconsin Lutheran |
| Co-Coaches of the Year: | Kevin Doherty, Lakeland & Lonnie Pries, Concordia Chicago |
| First Team All-Northern Athletics Conference | ||||
| Offense | ||||
| Mike Marotta | Concordia Chicago | QB | Jr. | Brookfield, Ill. (Riverside-Brookfield) |
| Khyree Copeland | Concordia Chicago | RB | Jr. | Jacksonville, Fla. (Potter's House) |
| Larry Hairl | Wisconsin Lutheran | RB | Jr. | Chicago, Ill. (Clemente) |
| Jeremy Williams | Lakeland | RB | So. | Zion, Ill. (Zion Benton) |
| Mike Egebrecht | Concordia Chicago | WR | Jr. | Wheeling, Ill. (Buffalo Grove) |
| Roberto Flores | Lakeland | WR | Jr. | Milwaukee, Wis. (Thomas More) |
| Jacob Heinemeyer | Lakeland | WR | Sr. | Shiocton, Wis. |
| Dominique Johnson | Wisconsin Lutheran | WR | Jr. | Milwaukee, Wis. (Vincent) |
| Eric Rusch | Concordia Wisconsin | TE | Sr. | Jackson, Wis. (Kettle Moraine Lutheran) |
| Matt Calcagnini | Concordia Wisconsin | OL | Fr. | Naples, Fla. (Ley) |
| Aaron Kraemer | Lakeland | OL | Jr. | Oshkosh, Wis. (North) |
| Quarandus Taylor | Benedictine | OL | Sr. | Chicago, Ill. (Curie) |
| Mason Thompson | Concordia Chicago | OL | Jr. | Ocala, Fla. (Vanguard) |
| Pete Thompson | Benedictine | OL | Sr. | Creston, Ill. (Rochelle Township) |
| Defense | ||||
| Pat Funk | Aurora | DL | Sr. | Morris, Ill. |
| Kaylan Gaines | Wisconsin Lutheran | DL | Jr. | Lake Worth, Fla. (American Heritage) |
| Eddie Hill Jr. | Benedictine | DL | Sr. | Chicago Heights, Ill. (Bloom Trail) |
| Jacob Pfeiffer | Concordia Wisconsin | DL | Jr. | Sheboygan, Wis. (South) |
| Mike Budzinski | Aurora | LB | Sr. | Minooka, Ill. |
| Alex Dewey | Benedictine | LB | Sr. | Geneseo, Ill. |
| Anthony Hoitink | Concordia Wisconsin | LB | So. | Sheboygan, Wis. (South) |
| Josh McCormick | Wisconsin Lutheran | LB | Jr. | Fond du Lac, Wis. (Winnebago Lutheran) |
| Devin Montgomery | Benedictine | LB | Sr. | Zion, Ill. (Zion-Benton) |
| Jarin Davis | Concordia Chicago | DB | Sr. | Jacksonville, Fla. (Potter's House) |
| Matt McWilliams | Benedictine | DB | So. | Belleville, Mich. (Divine Child) |
| Justin Rogers | Concordia Wisconsin | DB | So. | Milwaukee, Wis. (Vincent) |
| Keith Woodson | Lakeland | DB | Jr. | Evanston, Ill. (Evanston Township) |
| Special Teams | ||||
| Derek Powell | Aurora | P | Fr. | Colfax, Ill. (Ridgeview) |
| Neal Revane | Benedictine | P | Sr. | Villa Park, Ill. (Montini Catholic) |
| Daniel Winsey | Concordia Wisconsin | K | Jr. | Tampa, Fla. (Sickles) |
| Jeremiah Montgomery | Rockford | KR/PR | Fr. | Chicago, Ill. (Morgan Park) |
| Second Team All-Northern Athletics Conference | ||||
| Offense | ||||
| Jacob Dworak | Lakeland | QB | Jr. | Denmark, Wis. |
| John Alessi | Benedictine | RB | Fr. | Tinley Park, Ill. (Andrew) |
| Jason Hosey | Rockford | RB | Jr. | Chicago, Ill. (Prosser) |
| Adam Miller | Lakeland | RB | Jr. | Marion, Wis. |
| Ryne Reder | Aurora | RB | Sr. | Aurora, Ill. (Marmion Academy) |
| Rob Dupre | Maranatha | WR | Sr. | Lafayette, Ind. (Faith Christian) |
| Savonte Hunt | Concordia Chicago | WR | So. | Archer, Fla. (Buchholz) |
| Tim Young | Aurora | WR | Sr. | Aurora, Ill. (Christian) |
| Eric Zuelsdorf | Lakeland | TE | Jr. | Cedar Grove, Wis. (Cedar Grove Belgium) |
| Tyler Burke | Benedictine | OL | Sr. | Bradley, Ill. (Bradley-Bourbonnais) |
| Matt Laabs | Concordia Wisconsin | OL | Jr. | Manitowoc, Wis. (Valders) |
| Anthony Pennella | Concordia Chicago | OL | So. | Elmhurst, Ill. (York Community) |
| Ben Stellmacher | Lakeland | OL | Sr. | Waukesha, Wis. (West) |
| Phil Sturm | Maranatha | OL | Sr. | Los Angeles, Calif. (Faith Baptist) |
| Defense | ||||
| Justin Cromas | Wisconsin Lutheran | DL | Sr. | Greenfield, Wis. |
| David Dwyer | Concordia Chicago | DL | So. | St. Louis, Mo. (Ladue Horton Watkins) |
| Josh Gordon | Lakeland | DL | Sr. | Pontiac, Mich. |
| Dan Kleppin | Benedictine | DL | Jr. | Morton Grove, Ill. (Niles West) |
| Caleb Rader | Maranatha | LB | So. | Kinross, Mich. (Maplewood Baptist) |
| Nate Rosenberg | Wisconsin Lutheran | LB | Jr. | Hortonville, Wis. (Fox Valley Lutheran) |
| Jamie Schramm | Lakeland | LB | Sr. | Cuba City, Wis. |
| Malcom Godwin | Concordia Chicago | DB | So. | Ocala, Fla. (Vanguard) |
| Mike Hatfield | Benedictine | DB | Jr. | Madison Heights, Mich. (Bishop Foley) |
| Paul Metcalfe | Concordia Wisconsin | DB | Sr. | Glendale, Wis. (Madison East) |
| Joey O'Brien | Lakeland | DB | Sr. | Cary, Ill. (Cary-Grove) |
| Special Teams | ||||
| Philip Chaltis | Wisconsin Lutheran | K | Fr. | Bradenton, Fla. (Manatee) |
| Shem Biebert | Wisconsin Lutheran | P | Jr. | Inver Grove Heights, Minn. (St. Croix Luth.) |
| Justin Laack | Lakeland | KR/PR | Fr. | Sheboygan Falls, Wis. |
| Honorable Mention | ||||
| Kaz Duran | Concordia Wisconsin | RB | Jr. | West Palm Beach, Fla. (Palm Beach Gardens) |
| Kenneth McNeal | Rockford | RB | Sr. | Chicago, Ill. (Prosser) |
| Cody Harms | Wisconsin Lutheran | OL | Sr. | Blair, Wis. (Blair-Taylor) |
| Ben Baskin | Maranatha | DL | Sr. | Torrington, Conn. |
| Lucas Clausen | Rockford | DL | Jr. | Roscoe, Ill. (Hononegah) |
| Mike DeVries | Aurora | DL | Sr. | Princeville, Ill. |
| Steve Donovan | Benedictine | DL | Sr. | Chicago, Ill. (St. Patrick's) |
| Kellen Grott | Lakeland | DL | Sr. | New Holstein, Wis. |
| Matt Lechler | Concordia Wisconsin | DL | Fr. | Kiel, Wis. (New Holsten) |
| Ethan Rosen | Maranatha | DL | So. | New Munich, Minn. (Melrose) |
| Chris Scott | Rockford | DL | Jr. | Morrison, Ill. |
| Justin Tlachac | Concordia Wisconsin | DL | Sr. | Luxemburg, Wis. (Luxemburg Casco) |
| Brent Alexander | Rockford | LB | Jr. | LeRoy, Ill. |
| Will Baldwin | Lakeland | LB | Jr. | Waukegan, Ill. (Carmel) |
| Andrew Hobus | Concordia Wisconsin | LB | Jr. | Orange, Calif. (Milwaukee Lutheran) |
| Josh Ross | Rockford | LB | Jr. | Elgin, Ill. (Larkin) |
| Jason Talos | Concordia Chicago | LB | Jr. | Chicago, Ill. (Guerin Prep) |
| Curtis Underwood | Concordia Chicago | LB | Jr. | Delray Beach, Fla. (Pope John Paul II) |
| Tony Faller | Lakeland | DB | So. | Theinsville, Wis. (Oostburg) |
| Jimmy Fierro | Aurora | DB | Jr. | Carol Stream, Ill. (Glenbard North) |
