Baseball

• 2011: Concordia Chicago
• 2010: Edgewood & Rockford
• 2009: Concordia Chicago
• 2008: Benedictine & Rockford
• 2007: Rockford

Men's Basketball

• 2010-11: Benedictine
• 2009-10: Aurora
• 2008-09: Aurora
• 2007-08: Aurora
• 2006-07: Aurora

Women's Baksetball

• 2010-11: Wisconsin Lutheran
• 2009-10: Lakeland
• 2008-09: Concordia Wisconsin
• 2007-08: Concordia Wisconsin
• 2006-07: Concordia Wisconsin

Men's Cross Country

• 2010
  • Team: Concordia Wisconsin
  • Individual: Andy Ashenden, Concordia Wisconsin
• 2009
  • Team: Edgewood
  • Individual: Andy Ashenden, Concordia Wisconsin
• 2008
  • Team: Rockford
  • Individual: Zach Shiels, Wisconsin Lutheran
• 2007
  • Team: MSOE
  • Individual: Micah Lorenzen, Concordia Wisconsin
• 2006
  • Team: Aurora
  • Individual: Micah Lorenzen, Concordia Wisconsin

Women's Cross Country

• 2010
  • Team: Concordia Wisconsin
  • Individual: Katie Schommer, Wisconsin Lutheran
• 2009
  • Team: Concordia Wisconsin
  • Individual: Samantha Gries, Concordia Wisconsin
• 2008
  • Team: Aurora
  • Individual: Megan Vaccaro, Dominican
• 2007
  • Team: Concordia Wisconsin
  • Individual: Morgan Jacquette, Aurora
• 2006
  • Team: Aurora
  • Individual: Fran Sikorski, Aurora

Football

• 2010: Benedictine
• 2009: Lakeland
• 2008: Aurora

Men's Golf

• 2010
  • Team: Edgewood
  • Individual: Dane Zachman, MSOE
• 2009
  • Team: Aurora
  • Individual: Aaron Gavin, Edgewood
• 2008
  • Team: MSOE
  • Individual: R.J. Schwalabach, Benedictine
• 2007
  • Team: MSOE
  • Individual: Daniel Behm, Wisconsin Lutheran
• 2006
  • Team: Edgewood
  • Individual: Bob Stilling, Edgewood

Women's Golf

• 2010
  • Team: Concordia Wisconsin
  • Individual: Muriel McIntyre, Concordia Wisconsin
• 2009
  • Team: Concordia Wisconsin
  • Individual: Muriel McIntyre, Concordia Wisconsin
• 2008
  • Team: Aurora
  • Individual: Muriel McIntyre, Concordia Wisconsin
• 2007
  • Team: Aurora
  • Individual: Kristen Richardson, Aurora
• 2006
  • Team: Aurora
  • Individual: Nicole Gluzinski, Edgewood

Men's Soccer

• 2010: Dominican
• 2009: Dominican
• 2008: Dominican
• 2007: Dominican
• 2006: Dominican

Women's Soccer

• 2010: Aurora
• 2009: Aurora
• 2008: Aurora
• 2007: Aurora
• 2006: Aurora

Softball

• 2011: Benedictine
• 2010: Benedictine
• 2009: Aurora
• 2008: Aurora
• 2007: Aurora

Men's Tennis

• 2011
  • Team: Concordia Wisconsin
  • Individual: Brian Tresedder, Concordia Wisconsin
• 2010: MSOE
• 2009: Concordia Wisconsin
• 2008: Concordia Wisconsin
• 2007: Concordia Wisconsin

Women's Tennis

• 2010-11
  • Team: Benedictine, Concordia Wisconsin & Edgewood
  • Individual: MaryClare Loughery, Benedictine
• 2009-10: Edgewood
• 2008-09: Edgewood
• 2007-08: Concordia Wisconsin
• 2006-07: Concordia Wisconsin

Men's Indoor Track & Field

• 2011: MSOE
• 2010: Concordia Wisconsin
• 2009: Concordia Wisconsin
• 2008: MSOE
• 2007: Aurora

Women's Indoor Track & Field

• 2011: Aurora
• 2010: Concordia Chicago
• 2009: Concordia Wisconsin
• 2008: Concordia Wisconsin
• 2007: Concordia Wisconsin

Men's Outdoor Track & Field

• 2011: MSOE
• 2010: Concordia Wisconsin
• 2009: Concordia Wisconsin
• 2008: MSOE
• 2007: Concordia Wisconsin

Women's Outdoor Track & Field

• 2011: Concordia Wisconsin
• 2010: Concordia Wisconsin
• 2009: Concordia Wisconsin
• 2008: Concordia Wisconsin
• 2007: Concordia Wisconsin

Women's Volleyball

• 2010: Concordia Wisconsin
• 2009: Benedictine, Dominican, Lakeland
• 2008: Lakeland
• 2007: Lakeland
• 2006: Aurora